• English
  • 中文 (中国)
  • Español
  • 한국어
  • 모든 답변들

    제목 날짜 태그
    2004년말에 풀러 신학 대학(미국, 캘리포니아, 패사디나 소재)을 대표하는 세 명의 저명한 교수들인 리챠드 모우(Richard Mouw)총장, 하워드 로웬(Howard Loewen)신학 부장, 벨리 마티 커케년(Veli-Matti Karkkainen)조직신학 교수가 지방 교회들의 대표자들 그리고 워치만 니와 위트니스 리의 사역을 위한 출판사인 리빙스트림 미니스트리(LSM)의 대표자들과의 대화를 제안했습니다. 이 글은 우리가 풀러 측 교수들과 초기에 나눴던 대화 가운데 있던 쟁점들 중에서 다음과 같은 […]
    01/30/2017 공개 서한, 교단, 교회의 터, 구원, 믿는 이들의 하나, 복음의 수호, 삼일 하나님, 풀러 신학 대학
    이 책은 세 군데의 저명한 기독교 기관 인도자들이 지방 교회들의 정통성에 관하여 말한 진술문들을 싣고 있다: ‘크리스천 리서치 인스티튜트’(CRI)의 연구소장인 행크 해네그래프(Hank Hanegraaff), ‘행동하는 답변들’(AIA)의 대표인 그레첸 파산티노(Gretchen Passantino), 풀러 신학교: 총장인 리처드 모우(Richard Mouw), 신학부 학장인 하워드 로웬(Howard Loewen), 조직 신학 교수인 벨리-마티 카르카이넨(Veli-Matti Kärkkäinen). 이들의 진술들은 지방 교회들 안의 구성원들이 풀러 신학교 신학자들의 […]
    05/27/2016 그레첸 파산티노, 크리스천 리서치 인스티튜트 (CRI), 풀러 신학 대학, 행동하는 답변들 (AIA), 행크 해네그래프

    An index to the articles written in response to Walter Martin’s public criticisms of the teaching of Witness Lee and the local churches.

    10/13/2015 Orange County Register, Walter Martin
    2014년 6월 10일 월드 저널(World Journal)에 실린 광고가 포함된DCP 서한 PDF활용 가능 자료: English | 簡體中文 2014년 6월 4일 최근에 중국 내의 사건들에 대한 잘못된 정보를 바로 잡는 DCP서한 PDF활용 가능 자료: 한국의 | English | 傳統中文 | Español | Português 2014년 4월 29일 미국 국회 기록에 수록된 조셉 피츠( Joseph R. Pitts) 하원 의원이 […]
    05/08/2015 명단에서 제외함
    복음의 수호: “기독교 신학자들과 사역의 인도자들”이 보낸 공개 서한에 대한 답변은 2007년의 공개 서한이 위트니스 리의 사역과 지방 교회들 안에서 모이는 믿는 이들을 향해 반감을 갖게 하려고 문맥을 무시하고 인용한 열 일곱 개의 인용문들을 잘못 사용한 것을 직접 다루고 있다. 이것은 성경 안에 있는 신성한 계시에 대한 위트니스 리의 가르침이 신실하다는 것과 그러한 가르침들이 역대의 […]
    03/24/2015 공개 서한, 교단, 교회의 터, 구원, 믿는 이들의 하나, 복음의 수호, 삼일 하나님

    An index to responses written by members of the local churches to criticisms of the churches and of the ministry of Witness Lee.

    06/13/2014 church ground, deification, denominations, division, index, lawsuits, litigation, mingling, Norman Geisler, oneness of the believers, Open Letter, response, Ron Rhodes, scholars, Trinity, Triune God, Walter Martin

    An HTML version of Robert Govett’s classic study on The Twofoldness of Divine Truth, showing that biblical truth often has two sides which are not contradictory but complementary.

    06/13/2014 Arminianism, Calvinism, Robert Govett, Twofoldness of Divine Truth

    A series of articles addressing various deviations from biblical truth and false and hypocritical statements in an article posted on the Internet by Norman Geisler and Ron Rhodes. That article attacked the “We Were Wrong” issue of the Christian Research Journal and defended a 2007 open letter.

    06/12/2014 Christian Research Institute, Christian Research Journal, CRI, Elliot Miller, Hank Hanegraaff, index, Open Letter

    The articles on this site responding to criticisms of the local churches and the ministry of Witness Lee are centered around three primary issues—the Trinity, God’s complete salvation, and the practical expression of the church. The first round of responses were published in the 1970s in response to the criticisms of inexperienced apologists who had a limited understanding of biblical truth and even less of the ministry of Witness Lee. After an interim in which many additional resources presenting Witness Lee’s teachings were published, beginning from 1999 Harvest House Publishers and others associated with that company raised the same issues again, essentially repeating those earlier accusations without regard to the responses or other writings already published. Those renewed criticisms called forth a second round of responses.

    03/06/2014 church ground, deification, denominations, division, History, lawsuits, litigation, mingling, Norman Geisler, oneness of the believers, Open Letter, response, Ron Rhodes, scholars, Trinity, Triune God, Walter Martin

    지방 교회들의 구성원들은 위트니스 리와 지방 교회들의 가르침을 비판한 것들에 대해 많은 반박문들을 써 왔다. 이러한 반박문들은 하나님, 그리스도, 그분의 구원, 교회, 그외 다른 많은 주제들의 핵심 쟁점들을 다룬다.

    03/05/2014 1970년대의 출판물들, 고린도 전 서 15장 45절, 교회의 터, 구원, 그리스도와 그 영, 그리스도의 인격, 답변, 삼신론, 삼위일체, 삼일 하나님, 생각, 신앙, 아들과 아버지, 양태론, 이사야서 9장 6절
    리빙스트림 미니스트리에서 출판된 많은 간행물들을 읽고 세개의 대륙에 있는 지방 교회들을 방문하는 것을 포함하는 6년 간의 기초 조사 프로잭트를 수행한 후에, 전 세계에서 가장 존경받는 변증사역단체 중 하나인 ‘크리스천 리서치 인스티튜트’(CRI)는, 표지에 “우리가 틀렸었다”(We Were Wrong)라는 제목을 단 ‘크리스천 리서치 저널’(Christian Research Journal)의 한 특집호에 그들이 발견한 것들을 일련의 기사들로써서 출판 했다. 그 특집호는 위트니스 […]
    03/05/2014 공개 서한, 그레첸 파산티노, 엘리옷 밀러, 우리가 틀렸었다, 지방 교회들, 크리스천 리서치 인스티튜트 (CRI), 크리스천 리서치 저널, 행동하는 답변들 (AIA), 행크 해네그래프, 확증

    本书内容包括水流职事站针对 “基督教学者与事工领导人” 所写的公开信所作两次回应:简要的回应 〈2007〉和详尽的答覆〈2008〉。

    03/04/2014 三一神, 信徒的合一, 公会, 公开信, 召会立场, 救恩, 辩护福音

    A brief examination of some key verses concerning the Triune God (including Isaiah 9:6; 2 Corinthians 3:17; 1 Corinthians 15:45; and Matthew 28:19) and an appeal to accept the biblical revelation of the mystery of the Divine Trinity.

    11/16/2013 1 Corinthians 15:45, 2 Corinthians 3:17, Christ and the Spirit, Isaiah 9:6, the Son and the Father, Trinity, Triune God

    A 1978 booklet by Ron Kangas refuting the charge that Witness Lee taught that a person can be saved by calling on the name of the Lord apart from believing in Christ. In this booklet Ron Kangas shows that Witness Lee properly taught that:

    11/16/2013 calling on the Lord, salvation

    어떤 사람이 그리스도를 믿지 않아도 주님의 이름만 부르면 구원받을 수 있다고 위트니스 리가 가르친다는 참소에 대해 란 캔거스가 1987년에 쓴 소책자. 이 소 책자에서 란 캔거스는 위트니스 리가 다음과 같이 적절하게 가르쳤다는 것을 제시함.

    • 그리스도와 그분의 구속 사역을 믿는 것을 구원을 위하여 필수적임
    • 구원은 오직 믿음으로 받는 것임
    • 주님의 이름을 부르는 것은 믿음으로 하나님의 구원을 받아들이는 하나의 성경적인 길임
    11/16/2013 1970년대의 답변들, 구원, 주님을 부름

    A 1978 booklet by Ron Kangas refuting the charge that the local churches are exclusive. It discusses:

    11/16/2013 denominations, division, exclusivism, oneness of the believers

    A small booklet published in 1977 rebutting various false accusations by the Spiritual Counterfeits Project.

    11/16/2013 coexistence, cosmic Christ, cult accusation, Eastern mysticism, modalism, pantheism, Sabellianism, Trinity, Triune God

    本书包含一系列文章, 纠正近日盖斯勒(Norman Geisler)与罗德斯(Ron Rhodes)所发表之文章中,一些毫无根据的指控。本书将以事实回应其断言,并揭示:

    • 关于地方召会以兴讼压制教义批评的指控,是以不实传言为据。
    • 伪灵剖析会(SCP)宣告破产,以逃避法院对其之判决。
    • 罗德斯对穗仓出版社(Harvest House)一案,作出许多不实陈述。
    06/30/2011 Harvest House出版社, 伪灵剖析会 (SCP), 假见证, 好讼态度, 弟兄们,请听我们分诉, 法律诉讼, 盖斯勒 (Norman Geisler), 罗德斯 (Ron Rhodes)

    自改教以来,许多基督教教师在神话语的光中,批判过基督教国的光景。作为主忠信的仆人,倪柝声与李常受,亦根据圣经阐明基督教国的情形,其结果值得所有爱召会 并关心其权益的人加以重视。近日盖斯勒(Norman Geisler)与罗德斯(Ron Rhodes ) 批评李常受对基督教国所作的评论时,在李氏丰沛的著作中,只取出一章中的片语只字,还断章取义加以滥用。本书将检视两人如何:

    • 不实的将李常受批评基督教系统一事,视为对基督徒之攻击
    • 对李常受批评罗马天主教一事不实的陈述
    • 以双重标准对待有关对罗马天主教的评论此评论应促使基督教护教人士,决意提升治学水平,期以正直服事真理。
    06/30/2011 基督教, 天主教, 弟兄们,请听我们分诉, 盖斯勒 (Norman Geisler), 罗德斯 (Ron Rhodes), 虚伪

    本书以一系列文章,说明关于神圣三一真理的要点。本书将阐明下列各项错谬:

    • 坚持以“身位”一辞为衡量正统之标准
    • 将承认神圣三一之三者同时并存并一同作工的人,视为异端
    • 否认以赛亚书九章六节里,子是永远的父的明言
    • 否认林后三章十七节保罗的明白的教导:主耶稣基督就是那灵
    06/30/2011 三一神, 互相內在, 人位, 以赛亚书 9:6, 公开信, 同工, 哥林多后书 3:17, 基督和那灵, 子与父, 弟兄们,请听我们分诉, 电子书, 盖斯勒 (Norman Geisler), 神圣三一, 等同, 罗德斯 (Ron Rhodes)

    本书一系列论及真理要点的文章,说明下述各项危机:

    • 以信经取代圣经,作为基督徒信仰及实行准则
    • 为护卫某一项圣经真理,而牺牲了另一项真理
    • 否认关于无限的神藉成肉体,成了有限之人的真理

    06/30/2011 信条, 圣经, 基督的人位, 基督的神人二性, 弟兄们,请听我们分诉, 权威, 电子书, 盖斯勒 (Norman Geisler), 真理的兩面性, 神成为人, 罗德斯 (Ron Rhodes), 调和, 道成肉身

    An evaluation of a claim by Norman Geisler and Ron Rhodes that the local churches did not follow the principles in Matthew 18 in their dealings with Harvest House Publishers, John Ankerberg, and John Weldon.

    01/01/2011 hypocrisy, Matthew 18, Norman Geisler, Ron Rhodes

    Seven points that contradict a defense published by Norman Geisler and Ron Rhodes of Harvest House’s history of filing lawsuits against fellow Christians.

    01/01/2011 1 Corinthians 6:1-8, Harvest House, hypocrisy, Norman Geisler, Ron Rhodes
    “공개서한”에 대한 노먼 가이슬러와 론 로우즈의 변증과 ‘크리스천 리서치 저널’(Christian Research Journal)의 지방 교회들 재평가에 대한 그들의 비평에 답변함 [영어 사이트] 이 글을 PDF 로도 읽을 수 있음 그러나 신성한 본성에 관하여, 우리는 아들께서 아버지와 공동으로 함께 일하지 않으시는 채로 아버지 홀로만 어떤 일을 하신다거나, 아들께서 성령과 동떨어져 특별한 어떤 행동을 하신다 는 식으로 배우지는 […]
    01/01/2010 가이슬러와 로데즈, 기사, 삼위일체, 삼일 하나님, 상호 내재, 페리코레시스, 학자, 협력
    “공개서한”에 대한 노먼 가이슬러와 론 로우즈의 변증과 ‘크리스천 리서치 저널’(Christian Research Journal)의 지방 교회들 재평가에 대한 그들의 비평에 답변함 [영어 사이트] 이 글을 PDF 로도 읽을 수 있음 이 문서에 다음의 글들이 인용되었다 해서 그것들이 각 항목의 해석에 있어서 위트니스 리와 지방 교회들의 가르침과 전적으로 일치한다거나, 지방 교회들 안에 있는 우리가 진리의 각 방면에서 그들에게 […]
    01/01/2010 가이슬러와 로데즈, 고린도 전 서 15장 45절, 고린도 후서 3장 17절, 공개 서한, 그리스도와 그 영, 기사, 노먼 가이슬러, 론 로우즈, 학자, 확증
    “공개서한”에 대한 노먼 가이슬러와 론 로우즈의 변증과 ‘크리스천 리서치 저널’(Christian Research Journal)의 지방 교회들 재평가에 대한 그들의 비평에 답변함 [영어 사이트] 이 글을 PDF 로도 읽을 수 있음 『확증과 비평:크리스천 사상저널』 (Affirmation & Critique: A Journal of Christian Thought) [영어 사이트] (A&C) 안에 소개된 신앙 고백서는 다음과 같다: 우리는 성경을 완전한 계시이자 유일하게 신성한 계시로 보며, […]
    01/01/2010 가이슬러와 로데즈, 기사, 노먼 가이슬러, 동시 존재, 론 로우즈, 삼신론, 삼위일체, 삼일 하나님, 상호 내재, 인격
    “공개서한”에 대한 노먼 가이슬러와 론 로우즈의 변증과 ‘크리스천 리서치 저널’(Christian Research Journal)의 지방 교회들 재평가에 대한 그들의 비평에 답변함 [영어 사이트] 이 글을 PDF 로도 읽을 수 있음 고후3:17- 더구나 주님은 그 영이십니다. 주님이신 그 영께서 계신 곳에는 자유가 있습니다. 고전15:45- 그러므로 성경에 기록된 대로 첫 사람 아담은 산 혼이 되었지만, 마지막 아담은 생명 주는 […]
    01/01/2010 가이슬러와 로데즈, 고린도 전 서 15장 45절, 고린도 후서 3장 17절, 그리스도와 그 영, 기사, 노먼 가이슬러, 동일시, 론 로우즈, 삼위일체, 삼일 하나님
    “공개서한”에 대한 노먼 가이슬러와 론 로우즈의 변증과 ‘크리스천 리서치 저널’(Christian Research Journal)의 지방 교회들 재평가에 대한 그들의 비평에 답변함 [영어 사이트] 이 글을 PDF 로도 읽을 수 있음 노먼 가이슬러와 론 로우즈는 위트니스 리와 지방 교회들을 재평가한 크리스천 리서치 저널(Christian Research Journal)에 실린 엘리옷 밀러의 글에 대한 비판에서, 지방 교회들이 이단 교리인 성부 고난설을 가르친다며 […]
    01/01/2010 가이슬러와 로데즈, 기사, 노먼 가이슬러, 동시 존재, 론 로우즈, 상호 내재, 성부 고난설, 엘리옷 밀러, 크리스천 리서치 저널, 페리코레시스, 학자됨의 기준
    “공개서한”에 대한 노먼 가이슬러와 론 로우즈의 변증과 ‘크리스천 리서치 저널’(Christian Research Journal)의 지방 교회들 재평가에 대한 그들의 비평에 답변함 [영어 사이트] 이 글을 PDF 로도 읽을 수 있음 약 30년 전에 미국에서 제일 처음으로 지방 교회들을 비판하는 자료들을 펴내는데 참여했던 베테랑 이단 변증가인 그레첸 파산티노(Gretchen Passantino)는 크리스천 리서치 저널(the Christian Research Journal)최근 특집호(“우리가 틀렸었다”)에서 열정적인 […]
    01/01/2010 가이슬러와 로데즈, 그리스도의 두 본성, 기사, 노먼 가이슬러, 론 로우즈, 무감각성, 삼위일체, 삼일 하나님, 상호 내재, 성부 고난설, 협력
    “공개서한”에 대한 노먼 가이슬러와 론 로우즈의 변증과 ‘크리스천 리서치 저널’(Christian Research Journal)의 지방 교회들 재평가에 대한 그들의 비평에 답변함 [영어 사이트] 이 글을 PDF 로도 읽을 수 있음 이사야9:6- 이는 한 아기가 우리에게 났고 한 아들을 우리에게 주신 바 되었는데 그의 어깨에는 정사를 메었고 그의 이름은 기묘자라, 모사라, 전능하신 하나님이라, 영존하시는 아버지라, 평강의 왕이라 할 […]
    01/01/2010 가이슬러와 로데즈, 기사, 노먼 가이슬러, 동일시, 론 로우즈, 상호 내재, 아들과 아버지, 이사야서 9장 6절

    An examination of whether the historic Christian creeds or the Bible should be the ultimate yardstick of truth in light of criticism from Norman Geisler and Ron Rhodes.

    01/01/2010 authority, Bible, creeds, hypocrisy, Norman Geisler, orthodoxy, Ron Rhodes

    While it is common (and not wrong) to refer to the Three of the Divine Trinity as three “persons,” the term persons is problematic because it can lead to misunderstanding. This article examines whether Norman Geisler was justified in criticizing a statement of faith in the journal Affirmation & Critique because it did not explicitly use the word persons in its definition of the Trinity.

    01/01/2010 coexistence, coinherence, Norman Geisler, persons, Ron Rhodes, Trinity, tritheism, Triune God

    In a single paragraph in which Norman Geisler and Ron Rhodes errantly accused Witness Lee and the local churches of teaching the heresy of patripassianism, they misattributed and misrepresented three quotes.

    01/01/2010 Christian Research Journal, coexistence, coinherence, Elliot Miller, Norman Geisler, patripassianism, perichoresis, Ron Rhodes, standards of scholarship

    This article refutes the false accusation of Norman Geisler and Ron Rhodes that the local churches teach patripassianism. It shows their error in asserting that affirming the involvement of the Father in the Son’s work is equivalent to of patripassianism and presents both the biblical record and a number of respected scholars that support the principle of the co-working of the Father and the Son (see also Scholars Who Affirm the Working Together of the Three of the Divine Trinity).

    01/01/2010 co-working, coinherence, impassibility, Norman Geisler, patripassianism, Ron Rhodes, Trinity, Triune God, two natures of Christ

    Excerpts from respected scholars who affirm that the Father, the Son, and the Spirit all work together and that the work of any of the Three involves the other Two.

    01/01/2010 co-working, coinherence, perichoresis, scholars, Trinity, Triune God

    Second Corinthians 3:17 says plainly, “And the Lord is the Spirit.” Many respected scholars recognize that “the Lord” in this verse refers to our Lord Jesus Christ. However, Norman Geisler and Ron Rhodes argue otherwise. This article shows their error. (See also Scholars and Bible Teachers Who Affirm That the Lord is the Spirit).

    01/01/2010 1 Corinthians 15:45, 2 Corinthians 3:17, Christ and the Spirit, identification, Norman Geisler, Ron Rhodes, Trinity, Triune God

    Isaiah 9:6 is a prophecy concerning the coming Messiah, Jesus Christ, who through incarnation is the Child born to us, yet the mighty God, and the Son given to us who is called “Eternal Father.” Witness Lee affirmed the perspicuous meaning of this verse based on the principle of coinherence, that is, the mutual indwelling of the Divine Trinity. For this, Norman Geisler and Ron Rhodes wrongly accused Witness Lee of heresy. This article shows their error.

    01/01/2010 coinherence, identification, Isaiah 9:6, Norman Geisler, Ron Rhodes, the Son and the Father

    A list of excerpts from respected scholars who affirm that 2 Corinthians 3:17, 1 Corinthians 15:45, and other verses identify the Lord Jesus Christ with the Spirit.

    01/01/2010 1 Corinthians 15:45, 2 Corinthians 3:17, affirmation, Christ and the Spirit, Norman Geisler, Open Letter, Ron Rhodes, scholars

    Norman Geisler criticized an article by Ron Kangas in which the latter said, “God is infinite, and man is finite, yet in Christ the two became one.” In his criticism Geisler both misrepresents what Ron Kangas said and deviates from the biblical revelation of both the Person of Christ and of the Divine Trinity.

    01/01/2010 God becoming man, incarnation, mingling, Norman Geisler, Person of Christ, Ron Rhodes, two natures of Christ

    A list of excerpts from respected scholars who affirm the biblical revelation that God became incarnated in Christ, joining the infinite God with finite man.

    01/01/2010 affirmation, God becoming man, incarnation, Person of Christ, scholars, two natures of Christ

    The Twofoldness of Divine Truth is a classic study by the British Bible teacher Robert Govett. Norman Geisler misattributed the principle Govett articulated, calling in “[Witness] Lee’s mysterious doctrine” and wrongly claimed that it contradicts a philosophical principle called “the law of noncontradiction.” This article sketches the scope of his error and links to both Govett’s original booklet and a more detailed examination of the application of Govett’s teaching in an Affirmation & Critique article by Ron Kangas.

    01/01/2010 Norman Geisler, Robert Govett, Twofoldness of Divine Truth

    In an article in the journal Affirmation & Critique Ron Kangas applies the principle set forth in Robert Govett’s The Twofoldness of Divine Truth to central truths in the Bible. These truths include salvation, Christ indwelling the believers and being at the right hand of God, Christ being both the only begotten and the firstborn Son, Christ having a body of flesh and bones yet also being the life-giving Spirit to indwell His believers, God being immutable yet processed and consummated in His economy, etc.

    01/01/2010 Robert Govett, Twofoldness of Divine Truth

    In an attempt to scandalize fellow believers, Norman Geisler and Ron Rhodes strung together a series of quote fragments in a way that completely misrepresented Witness Lee’s biblical critique of the deviations from the biblical patternof the system of organized Christianity that has developed over the centuries. This article examines the true nature and content of that critique as well as the attitude of Witness Lee and the local churches toward fellow believers in Christ.

    01/01/2010 Christianity, denominations, division, false witness, Matthew 13, Norman Geisler, Ron Rhodes

    This article exposes the way Norman Geisler and Ron Rhodes used a dishonest and hypocritical apologetic method to attack Witness Lee’s biblically-based criticisms of the Roman Catholic Church.

    01/01/2010 Babylon, Catholicism, Matthew 13, Norman Geisler, Ron Rhodes

    Norman Geisler and Ron Rhodes castigated Witness Lee for criticizing the Roman Catholic Church when they and apologists with whom they associate have made similar and even more severe statements concerning it.

    01/01/2010 ATRI, Catholicism, Harvest House, hypocrisy, John Ankerberg, John Weldon, Norman Geisler, Ron Rhodes

    A list of biblical critiques of scholars and Bible teachers whose teachings parallel Witness Lee’s expositions concerning the parable of the mustard seed in Matthew 13:31-32; the parable of the woman, the leaven, and the fine flour in Matthew 13:33-35; the identity of Thyatira and Jezebel in Revelation 2:18-29; and the prophetic identity of Babylon the Great in chapters 16 through 18 of Revelation. At the end of the list are biographical sketches of the authors cited.

    01/01/2010 Christianity, Norman Geisler, Ron Rhodes, scholars

    An evaluation of the accusation that the local churches are “litigious.” That accusation was based on false claims of legal threats with respect to Christian Research Institute, James Bjornstad and Regal Books, Salem Kirban, Jerram Barrs and InterVarsity Press, and Moody Press. The local churches’ application of an appropriate standard for considering legal action is evident also in dealings with Jesus People USA and Geisler and Rhodes themselves. While Geisler and Rhodes condemn the local churches for their appeals to the courts, they do not criticize those who have borne false witness against us and have, in fact, joined with them in propagating falsehoods.

    01/01/2010 Christian Research Institute, CRI, false witness, litigiousness, Norman Geisler, Ron Rhodes, SCP, Spiritual Counterfeits Project, The God-Men, The Mindbenders

    Norman Geisler and Ron Rhodes repeated a falsehood that is accepted as axiomatic among some countercult apologists, namely, that the local churches drove SCP into bankruptcy. From source documents this article looks at the actual causes and motivating factors behind SCP’s bankruptcy declaration.

    01/01/2010 false witness, Neil Duddy, Norman Geisler, Ron Rhodes, SCP, Spiritual Counterfeits Project, The God-Men

    An examination of how Norman Geisler and Ron Rhodes misrepresented the subject and scope of the libel lawsuit over the Encyclopedia of Cults and New Religions, the content of that book, and of the court’s decision in the case.

    01/01/2010 ECNR, Encyclopedia of Cults and New Religions, false witness, Harvest House, John Ankerberg, John Weldon, libel, litigation, Norman Geisler, Ron Rhodes
    이 글을 해당 언어로 보기 원하면 관련 버튼을 누르기 바람: 서문에서 가져옴 지방 교회들: “진정한 믿는이들이자그리스도의 몸의같은 지체들”(PDF 내려받기): 여러 해에 걸쳐서 지방 교회들은 우리의 신앙과 실행을 이해하기 위해 정직하고 철저한 연구조사를 수행하고자 했던 학자들과의 대화를 환영하였습니다. 우리는 지난 5 년 이상 그러한 연구자들과 학자들과 함께 대화를 나누고 그리스도인의 교통을 하는데 참여할 수 있는 특권을 […]
    11/30/2008 그레첸 파산티노, 리처드 모우, 벨리-마티 카르카이넨, 엘리옷 밀러, 우리가 틀렸었다, 크리스천 리서치 인스티튜트 (CRI), 풀러 신학 대학, 하워드 로웬, 행동하는 답변들 (AIA), 행크 해네그래프, 확증

    In various venues Harvest House President Robert Hawkins and authors John Ankerberg and John Weldon have misled the public regarding the local churches and facts surrounding the litigation over the Encyclopedia of Cults and New Religions.

    10/23/2006 ECNR, Encyclopedia of Cults and New Religions, Harvest House, John Ankerberg, John Weldon, public statement, Robert Hawkins

    Harvest House and its authors John Ankerberg and John Weldon sought to make the local churches repulsive in the eyes of the Christian public using out-of-context quotation and misrepresenting our Scripture-based rejection of unbiblical teachings, practices and institutions as a rejection of fellow believers and of the faith. In doing so, they pervert Witness Lee’s plea for recovery to the biblical standards of life, service, and testimony among Christians.

    10/23/2006 Christianity, clergy-laity, denominations, division, ECNR, Encyclopedia of Cults and New Religions, Harvest House, hypocrisy, John Ankerberg, John Weldon, oneness of the believers, recovery, subjective experience of Christ

    The local churches seek to return to the biblical standard concerning the subjective experience of Christ, the function of every member of the Body of Christ, and the practical testimony of the oneness of the Body of Christ. Harvest House, John Ankerberg, and John Weldon misrepresent Witness Lee’s biblically-based critique of organized Christianity on these three lines, even though they and their associates acknowledge the same deficiencies in Christendom today.

    10/23/2006 Christianity, denominations, division, ECNR, Encyclopedia of Cults and New Religions, Harvest House, hypocrisy, John Ankerberg, John Weldon, oneness of the believers

    Harvest House feigns indignation over our criticism of organized Christianity, yet their own books contain very harsh statements criticizing evangelical Christianity, Christianity and the church generally, and the Roman Catholic Church specifically. They even attack prominent evangelicals such as Billy Graham.

    10/23/2006 Christianity, denominations, ECNR, Encyclopedia of Cults and New Religions, Harvest House, hypocrisy, John Ankerberg, John Weldon

    The Encyclopedia of Cults and New Religions by John Ankerberg and John Weldon (Eugene, OR: Harvest House Publishers, 1999) accuses the local churches of rejecting Christianity, implying that we reject fellow believers and the Christian faith.The authors and their publisher have never corrected this deceit despite extensive documentation provided to Harvest House proving the contrary.

    10/23/2006 Christianity, church ground, clergy-laity, ECNR, Encyclopedia of Cults and New Religions, Harvest House, hypocrisy, John Ankerberg, John Weldon, subjective experience of Christ

    Harvest House has attempted to turn Christians against the local churches with a series of out-of-context quotations posted on its corporate website. This article contextualizes those quotes and exposes Harvest House’s unfaithfulness to the Bible and to the Lord’s church in misrepresenting the teaching of Witness Lee.

    10/23/2006 Christianity, church ground, clergy-laity, division, ECNR, Encyclopedia of Cults and New Religions, Harvest House, John Ankerberg, John Weldon, oneness of the believers, subjective experience of Christ

    Harvest House publicly accused the local churches of being litigious. This article contrasts the history of the local churches’ appeals for relief from character defamation with Harvest House’s lawsuits against fellow Christians over financial disputes.

    10/23/2006 1 Corinthians 6:1-8, ECNR, Encyclopedia of Cults and New Religions, Harvest House, John Ankerberg, John Weldon, litigiousness, SCP, Spiritual Counterfeits Project, The God-Men, The Mindbenders

    An introduction to a series of articles on how Harvest House misrepresented the local churches’ appeal for relief from libel and our objections to the Encyclopedia of Cults and New Religions.

    10/23/2006 ECNR, Encyclopedia of Cults and New Religions, Harvest House, John Ankerberg, John Weldon

    Harvest House attempted to recast the litigation over the Encyclopedia of Cults and New Religions as a theological dispute, but a reading of the libel complaint filed in The Local Church et al v. Harvest House et al shows this claim to be false.

    10/23/2006 Christianity Today, ECNR, Encyclopedia of Cults and New Religions, Harvest House, John Ankerberg, John Weldon

    John Ankerberg and his attorney Shelby Sharpe both claimed that the local churches registered no objections to “The Local Church” chapter. This article shows that their claims are false and misleading.

    10/23/2006 Christianity Today, ECNR, Encyclopedia of Cults and New Religions, Fuller Theological Seminary, Harvest House, hypocrisy, John Ankerberg, John Weldon

    On a syndicated radio broadcast Harvest House President Bob Hawkins, Jr., gave a distorted account of the history of the local churches’ protests over the Encyclopedia of Cults and New Religions. This article contrasts the statements he made on the air with the actual facts.

    10/23/2006 ECNR, Encyclopedia of Cults and New Religions, Harvest House, History, John Ankerberg, John Weldon, letters of protest, Matthew 18

    To mislead both the court and the public, Harvest House portrayed the nature of the definition of cult in the Encyclopedia of Cults and New Religions as purely theological in nature. This article shows the falsehood and duplicity of that claim.

    10/23/2006 cult accusation, ECNR, Encyclopedia of Cults and New Religions, Harvest House, John Ankerberg, John Weldon

    A public statement concerning the decision to appeal the Court of Appeals decision which granted Harvest House, John Ankerberg, and John Weldon summary judgment in the libel action over the Encyclopedia of Cults and New Religions.

    02/27/2006 ECNR, Encyclopedia of Cults and New Religions, Harvest House, John Ankerberg, John Weldon, public statement

    An examination of what the Bible says about how Christians should deal with disputes and under what circumstances an appeal to a secular court system may be justified.

    12/05/2005 1 Corinthians 6:1-8, lawsuits, litigation, Matthew 18

    A press release concerning public postings on Harvest House’s corporate website libeling the local churches.

    04/20/2004 ECNR, Encyclopedia of Cults and New Religions, Harvest House, John Ankerberg, John Weldon, public statement

    Ten irrefutable facts about the Encyclopedia of Cults and New Religions that show reckless disregard for the truth and malice on the part of both the authors and the publisher in including the local churches in the book.

    04/20/2004 ECNR, Encyclopedia of Cults and New Religions, Harvest House, John Ankerberg, John Weldon, litigation, public statement, publishing standards

    Harvest House claimed to use “professional editorial standards” in the development and publishing of the Encyclopedia of Cults and New Religions. This article shows the emptiness of those claims.

    04/20/2004 ECNR, Encyclopedia of Cults and New Religions, Harvest House, John Ankerberg, John Weldon, public statement, publishing standards

    Harvest House claimed that its use of The Chicago Manual of Style discharged its responsibility to use “acceptable editorial standards” in publishing the Encyclopedia of Cults and New Religions. The Chicago Manual, however, focuses on stylistic and not substantive issues and cannot be used to justify shirking editorial norms in publishing a book that makes false and defamatory accusations.

    04/20/2004 ECNR, Encyclopedia of Cults and New Religions, Harvest House, John Ankerberg, John Weldon, public statement, publishing standards

    A press release responding to a Harvest House statement on its corporate website following the District Court’s rejection of its summary judgment motion.

    03/19/2004 ECNR, Encyclopedia of Cults and New Religions, First Amendment, Harvest House, John Ankerberg, John Weldon, public statement

    An historical overview of the controversy surrounding Walter Martin’s criticisms of the teaching of Witness Lee and the local churches.

    03/01/1994 Orange County Register, Walter Martin

    The oneness of the Triune God can be seen in three categories of Scriptures, which this article calls interpenetration, identification, and interchangeable Scriptures.

    03/04/1978 2 Corinthians 3:17, Christ and the Spirit, coinherence, Isaiah 9:6, Orange County Register, the Son and the Father, Trinity, Triune God, Walter Martin

    This article points out key faults in arguments concerning the Triune God presented in the pamphlet The Teachings of Witness Lee and The Local Church. It contrasts:

    02/25/1978 coinherence, Orange County Register, Sabellianism, Trinity, Triune God, Walter Martin

    This article gives brief rebuttals to accusations in the pamphlet The Teachings of Witness Lee and The Local Church concerning:

    02/11/1978 Bible, denominations, division, oneness of the believers, Orange County Register, Trinity, Triune God, Walter Martin

    God is moving today to recover what was lost by the historic Christian church. This article presents:

    02/04/1978 Orange County Register, recovery, subjective experience of Christ, Walter Martin

    Those who desire to return to the “historic Christian church” should consider the epistles to the seven churches in [Revelation chapters 2 and 3]. The prophecies there trace the historic development of the church and its degradation from the New Testament standard.

    01/22/1978 Christianity, clergy-laity, oneness of the believers, Orange County Register, recovery, Walter Martin

    Calls to return to “historic Christianity” as represented by the great ecumenical councils are misguided. This article gives many examples of deviations from the Bible brought in through some of those councils.

    01/21/1978 Christianity, creeds, Walter Martin

    Those who call for a return to “historic Christianity” should consider the Lord’s speaking in Matthew 13, in which He prophesied concerning the deviation of the church from His original desire and intention.

    01/21/1978 Christianity, creeds, Walter Martin

    A rebuttal of Walter Martin’s claim that the Roman Catholic Church does not teach or practice idolatry.

    01/14/1978 Catholicism, Orange County Register, Walter Martin

    A critique showing that Walter Martin’s explanation that the Three of the Divine Trinity are separate persons sharing an ill-defined common nature is tantamount to having three separate Gods.

    01/07/1978 Orange County Register, Sabellianism, Trinity, tritheism, Triune God, Walter Martin

    1978년에 리빙스트림 미니스트리가 출판한 이 소책자는 다음과 같은 내용을 담고 있다:

    • 지방 교회들의 신앙, 입장, 위임, 소망
    • “주님의 회복”의 표현이라는 말의 의미
    • 구원, 그리스도인의 생활, 교회 생활에 관한 몇 가지 기본적인 진리들.

    이 소책자는 또한 지방 교회들의 신앙과 실행들에 관해 그 당시에 제기되었던 몇 가지 질문들에 대해 답변한다.

    01/01/1978 1970년대의 출판물들, 교회의 터, 구원, 기도로 말씀읽기, 믿는 이들의 하나, 신앙, 양태론, 회복

    A critique of Walter Martin’s insistence that Christ is not actually present but is only represented in the believers by the Holy Spirit.

    12/31/1977 identification, Isaiah 9:6, Orange County Register, the Son and the Father, Trinity, Triune God, Walter Martin

    An affirmation of the biblical truth that the believers partake of the divine nature in contrast with Walter Martin’s preference that “nature” in 2 Peter 1:4 be translated as “attribute” instead.

    12/24/1977 2 Peter 1:4, Orange County Register, partakers of the divine nature, Walter Martin

    An examination of Walter Martin’s claimed educational credentials.

    12/24/1977 Orange County Register, Walter Martin

    The writer of this article called on Walter Martin to correct errors spoken in public concerning Witness Lee, the local churches, and vital biblical truths.

    12/10/1977 2 Corinthians 3:17, Christ and the Spirit, exclusivism, mingling, modalism, Orange County Register, partakers of the divine nature, pray-reading, Sabellianism, Walter Martin

    Some Christians believe that man has two only parts—body and soul. However, the biblical view that man has three parts—body, soul, and spirit—is vital to our experience of Christ.

    12/03/1977 1 Thessalonians 5:23, Orange County Register, soul, spirit, tripartite, Walter Martin

    Witness Lee used the expression “four-in-one” to express the marvelous reality that the Triune God and the believers in Christ mutually indwell one another (John 14:20; 17:21, 23). However, some have misrepresented this “four-in-one” mutual indwelling to falsely claim that Witness Lee makes the church part of the Godhead.

    11/05/1977 four-in-one, oneness of the believers, Orange County Register, standards of scholarship, Trinity, Triune God, Walter Martin

    Walter Martin brandished a single sentence from a footnote in the Recovery Version of the New Testament as “proof” that Witness Lee was anti-Christian. His out-of-context quotation of this sentence obscured Witness Lee’s biblical critique of the deviation of “isms” from the revelation in God’s Word.

    11/05/1977 Catholicism, Christianity, Orange County Register, Walter Martin

    In response to Walter Martin’s counseling of a radio listener to remain as a believer in Roman Catholicism, this article presents a biblical evaluation of the Roman Catholic Church who degradations caused the Lord Himself to cry, “Come out of her, my people” (Rev. 18:2).

    11/05/1977 Catholicism, Orange County Register, Walter Martin

    A consideration of mingling as the most accurate term to describe the union of God and man based on 2 Corinthians 3:17, 2 Timothy 4:22, and 1 Corinthians 6:17.

    11/05/1977 2 Corinthians 3:17, Christ and the Spirit, identification, mingling, Orange County Register, Trinity, Triune God, Walter Martin

    A brief exposition of the proper place of the subjective experience of Christ in the believers’ life as witnessed by the Holy Scriptures.

    11/05/1977 Orange County Register, subjective experience of Christ, Walter Martin

    To those who hold that Christ is only at the right hand of God and does not actually dwell in the believers, this article offers a strong biblical corrective.

    10/29/1977 Orange County Register, subjective experience of Christ, Walter Martin

    A clear biblical corrective to those who attempt to negate 2 Peter 1:4, which says the believers have the divine nature.

    10/29/1977 2 Peter 1:4, Orange County Register, partakers of the divine nature, Walter Martin

    A testimony that as believers in Christ we can enjoy Him as the one who dwells as the Spirit in our human spirit and who supplies Himself to us as the bread and water of life through His Word and our calling upon His name.

    10/29/1977 Orange County Register, subjective experience of Christ, Walter Martin

    A 1977 response to a speaker at Melodyland Christian Center who belittled members of the local churches as theologically untrained.

    10/22/1977 Orange County Register, Walter Martin

    A 1977 answer to Walter Martin’s claim that a footnote in the Recovery Version of the New Testament altered the meaning of a word in the Bible.

    10/22/1977 Bible, Orange County Register, Walter Martin

    A brief examination of some key verses in the New Testament on which Walter Martin erred and of his condoning of idolatry in the Roman Catholic Church.

    10/22/1977 1 Corinthians 15:45, 2 Corinthians 3:17, Catholicism, Christ and the Spirit, Orange County Register, subjective experience of Christ, Walter Martin

    An overview of the scriptural meaning of the Triune God, including the basic facts, the value of being limited to biblical terminology, the principle of the twofoldness of divine truth applied to the oneness and threeness of God, an understanding of how the Bible reveals the Triune God, the relationship among the Three in the Godhead, and the meaning of the Triune God in the believers’ experience.

    10/22/1977 coinherence, Orange County Register, Trinity, Triune God, Twofoldness of Divine Truth, Walter Martin

    An answer to Walter Martin’s accusations that Witness Lee and the local churches practice “dividing the Body of Christ,” “proselytizing among other Christian groups,” and “sheep stealing.”

    10/22/1977 church ground, division, oneness of the believers, Orange County Register, Walter Martin

    In this statement Witness Lee responds to criticism of his teachings by explaining three reasons for different understandings of the Scriptures:

    Witness Lee closes with an appeal for conduct becoming of Christians in disagreements of understandings of Scriptures.

    10/15/1977 Bible, oneness of the believers, Orange County Register, partakers of the divine nature, recovery, Trinity, Triune God, Walter Martin

    An Introduction and Conclusion that frame the controversy surrounding a speaking at Melodyland Christian Center in Anaheim in 1977.

    10/08/1977 Orange County Register, Walter Martin

    Two articles that point out flaws in criticisms of Witness Lee’s teaching concerning the Divine Trinity.

    10/08/1977 1 Corinthians 15:45, 2 Corinthians 3:17, Christ and the Spirit, Isaiah 9:6, modalism, Orange County Register, Sabellianism, the Son and the Father, Trinity, Triune God, Walter Martin

    A short article showing the basis for the teaching of the mingling of God and man in both the Old and New Testaments and how mingling is the most appropriate word to describe the relationship of the divine and human natures in Christ.

    10/08/1977 mingling, Orange County Register, Walter Martin

    A brief survey of the truth concerning the oneness of the church, both spiritually and practically, and of the truth that the church is God manifested in the flesh (1 Tim. 3:15-16).

    10/08/1977 2 Peter 1:4, church ground, oneness of the believers, Orange County Register, partakers of the divine nature, Walter Martin

    A return to “historic Christianity” and a creed-based faith would bind the church to the church councils that brought in many deviations from New Testament Christianity. The second and third parts of this post address the truth concerning Babylon and denominations.

    10/08/1977 Babylon, Christianity, creeds, denominations, division, oneness of the believers, Orange County Register, Walter Martin

    A short article on man in creation and in the fall with particular attention to the nature of indwelling sin and the needing to forgo the lust of the flesh.

    10/08/1977 fallen man, Orange County Register, Walter Martin

    A brief survey of the biblical revelation of God’s desire to enter into man.

    10/08/1977 Orange County Register, salvation, Walter Martin

    A brief look at the release of the spirit and its relationship to the practice of calling on the name of the Lord and at taking the Word of God through means of prayer, or pray-reading.

    10/08/1977 calling on the Lord, Orange County Register, pray-reading, Walter Martin

    This article decries the association of the local churches with cultic groups by a speaker at Melodyland Christian Center in Anaheim and his endorsement of The Mindbenders.

    10/08/1977 cult accusation, Jack Sparks, Orange County Register, The Mindbenders, Walter Martin

    A defense of Witness Lee by one of his co-workers against a personal attack launched by a speaker at Melodyland Christian Center in 1977.

    10/08/1977 Orange County Register, Walter Martin

    A 1977 response to a speaker at Melodyland Christian Center concerning the study of the Bible in the local churches, the Recovery Version of the Bible, and biblical interpretations related to the Divine Trinity.

    10/08/1977 2 Corinthians 3:17, Bible, Christ and the Spirit, Isaiah 9:6, Orange County Register, the Son and the Father, Twofoldness of Divine Truth, Walter Martin

    1977년에 란 캔거스가 쓴 이 소책자는 잭 스팍스가 <마인드밴더즈>라는 책에서 왜곡하고 있는 생각에 대한 거짓 참소는 다음과 같은 성경의 계시와 상반된다는 것을 검토함.

    • 생각의 정상적인 기능
    • 사람의 타락하고 천연적인 생각의 상태
    • 회개와 생각을 새롭게 할 필요성
    • 새롭게 됨이 발생하는 과정
    • 새로와진 생각의 특징들
    • 사람의 영과 생각 사이의 관계
    01/01/1977 ‘마인드밴더즈’, 1970년대의 출판물들, Jack Sparks, 데살로니가전서 5장 23절, 생각, 세 부분으로 된, , 타락한 사람,

    이 1977년 소책자에서, 위트니스 리는 자신의 가르침이 양태론적이라는 참소를 직접 반론한다. 그는 이사야 9장 6절, 고린도전서 15장 45절, 고린도후서 3장 17절과 같은 핵심 구절들의 검토를 통해, 그 구절들이 분명히 의미하는 것을 회피하려고 본문을 곡해한 일부 사람들이 결국 삼신론 이단이 되는 것을 보여준다. 위트니스 리는 삼일 하나님에 관한 성경적인 계시는 교리적인 공식을 위함이 아니라 그분의 백성들이 하나님의 실재를 체험토록 하려는 것임을 보여 주는 것으로 결론을 맺는다.

    01/01/1977 1970년대의 출판물들, 고린도 전 서 15장 45절, 고린도 후서 3장 17절, 그리스도와 그 영, 사벨리우스주의, 삼신론, 삼위일체, 삼일 하나님, 아들과 아버지, 양태론, 이단들, 이사야서 9장 6절, 회복

    란 캔거스가 쓰고 리빙스트림 미니스트리가 1976년에 출판한 소책자의 내용들은 다음과 같다:

    • 양태론과 삼신론 이단들을 정의하고 그것들이 역사적으로 발전된 것을 요약함,
    • 이 두 이단적인 치우침들을 균형있게 하려는 역사적인 시도들을 묘사함;
    • 그것을 신성한 삼일성에 적용하려고 신성한 진리의 양면성의 원칙을 검토함,
    • 삼일성을 이해하기 위하여 성경을 표준으로 사용할 필요성을 제시함,
    • 성경에 있는 삼일 하나님에 관한 기본 진리들을 분명하게 제시함
    • 삼일 하나님에 관한 성경적인 계시가 믿는 이들의 그리스도인의 체험에 의미하는 것을 설명함.
    11/16/1976 1970년대의 출판물들, 동시 존재, 동일시, 사벨리우스주의, 삼신론, 삼위일체, 삼일 하나님, 양태론, 이단들

    A 1976 booklet by Ron Kangas refuting criticisms that those in the local churches are modalists. The booklet:

    10/06/1976 1 Thessalonians 5:23, Isaiah 9:6, modalism, Sabellianism, subjective experience of Christ, the Son and the Father, Trinity, Triune God

    위트니스 리가 쓰고 리빙스트림 미니스트리가 1976년에 출판한, 삼일 하나님에 관한 그의 성경적인 가르침의 기초들을 제시한 소책자 내용:

    • 하나님은 유일하게 한분이심
    • 하나님은 삼일-아버지, 아들, 그영이시며, 셋 모두는
      • 하나님이심
      • 영원하심
      • 동시에 존재하심
      • 하나이심
      • 믿는 이들 안에 계심

    이 소책자는 삼일 하나님은 설명할 수 없는 비밀이시라는 단락과 신성한 삼일성에 관한 성경의 완전한 계시를 받아들일 것을 호소하는 것으로 결론지음.

    01/01/1976 1970년대의 출판물들, 고린도 전 서 15장 45절, 고린도 후서 3장 17절, 그리스도와 그 영, 동시 존재, 삼위일체, 삼일 하나님, 아들과 아버지, 이사야서 9장 6절
    목차 역대의 다양한 학설들 1. 그리스도께는 신성만 있고 인성은 없으심 2. 그리스도께는 인성만 있고 신성은 없으심 3. 그리스도의 신성은 불완전함 4. 그리스도의 인성은 불완전함 5. 그리스도의 신성과 인성은 분리되었음 6. 그리스도의 신성과 인성은 하나로 융합되었음 7. 그리스도는 신성과 인성을 둘 다 소유하심―각각 완전하면서도 한 인격체 안에서 결합됨 성경의 계시 1. 그리스도는 하나님이심 A. 구약에서 B. […]
    01/01/1971 1970년대의 출판물들